Wow Millertime! I do understand your frusteration. However, when I think of all the 30 plus pound slabs which get caught on the WCVI throughout the year, and this ONE fish was caught fair and square deep in legal waters in Vancouver and you've got your knickers in a knot...wow. VERY FEW of these big fish are caught where this fish was caught and it was totally unexpected and not targeted. If you look at all the fish taken out of the Fraser by Natives...now that's something to get angry about! Vancouver anglers do not target these fish at this time of year. The guest chose to keep his fish. That's the anglers and guests perogative.
The GUIDE tried to persuade the angler to let the fish go, to no avail. Unfortunate? Yes. However, if you really want to get excited....check out the HOG list taken from all the Charlottes lodges from May 15 to July 15..and you can't tell me those fish are all from healthy stocks.
If there's a fault here, it's the DFO, not the fisher.
Anyways, it is what it is and KUDOS to the guide for trying to get the guest to release it.