Woah man, it's like you've been reading my mind all weekend. I've been doing the same research. I've found this one a little on the small side, so I've been looking at those same two. The quality of the Magma is great, I too wouldn't spend the extra money on the Nauti. I'm sure it's marginally better but not worth it to me. The only thing I'm doing different this time is adding two posts at the front and pulling the table forward about 6". It's ok as a rigging station or for the odd fish or three. But I'm a little too slouched forward in its current position. The dual rail mounting also isn't adequate, I've had the table flip back in me when someone really leaned into it, lost all the gear on it. My new setup will have four mounting points. Oh and last thing, I didn't like that the Nauti was 3" longer but actually had less work surface because of the way they mount the sides inset a couple inches. Just kind of bugged me. Hope that helps!