The derailment of these threads is becoming far to common place. I have left some comments and removed the personal stuff. Interesting that their were comments that stated that they derided the OP for the handling of the fish but said they themselves would want a picture of that beauty. Just because you don't post a picture on a public sit doesn't make the taking of the pic any more right or wrong. The OP himself stated he hasn't been fishing because of C&R but that his Granddaughter wanted to fish so they did. Now they nail this beautiful fish, which I am sure would be something the Granddaughter has never accomplished before, so they take the pic. Reminds me a little of the reformed smoker, as I know I no longer take fish out of the water that I would have previously because I have photos of me with Tyee class fish, but I know my son would want to have his picture taken with this fish, as he has never had the good fortune to land one that size yet. I am not picking sides here, as I understand the unfortunate situation we as recreational fishers find ourselves in, but I would like to think we could find a way to have this conversation without the harsh judgement that seems to occur when someone posts a fish pic like this. We should be celebrating that young ladies accomplishment but alas, because of the situation we find ourselves in we somehow feel a sense of shame as a member of the fishing fraternity.
My suggestion is to continue this type of conversation in a thread already designated to the subject but, until there is yet another regulation added to the pile that says fish to be released may not be removed from the water, I am loath to condemn people here from finding a little joy and creating a photo memory for their family members.
Lastly, please keep these conversations out of the reports area...there is enough negativity floating around the recreational fishery as it is.
Brian
