So, here is my review on the CFR GL1 reel after using it on a few recent trips to Esperanza and Bamfield. It took a long time to get the reel but it is a small one man operation and all of their reels are custom. It was about $1000 so fairly comparable to a TR3 in price.
Reel is pretty good looking and the craftsmanship is pretty evident. As far as operation, it is actually a simple reel to use. Operates like any other single wind reel but the drag lever (not a dial like an Islander) is on the opposite side of the reel. Liked the clicker noise (reminds you of a Peetz) when line starts to peel.
For the most part, it is very similar to using an Islander with the exception that it picks up line twice as quick. It really takes some time to get used to. Almost felt clunky when trying to reel in line until your brain makes the connection that you don't have to reel as fast. And, when fishing a flasher, it is very evident as you can only reel in so fast due to the flasher drag.
The single advantage of the reel is its ability to pick up line quickly when a Spring is running at the boat. It allows you to keep a fish tighter much easier. The drag system is also very smooth and precise and won't birdsnest or creep like an MR3. I think that it would also feel better if you are fishing spoons, bait, or plugs without a flasher.
All that being said, I still prefer my TR3 at this stage. Probably due to just familiarity. I would take the CFR over the MR3 though. Going to keep fishing it and see if it become my favourite but I have a lot of muscle memory with Islander reels.
For someone newer to fishing Springs or once you get used to it, you would probably lose less fish due to your ability to pick up line quickly, and I think that once you get used to it, most people would be very happy.
www.canadafishingreels.com
