Too many boats.. what would you do?

jcon12

Well-Known Member
Hi all,

My dad and I are both boat enthusiasts and have found ourselves with too many boats. Simply a problem I never thought could exist.

My family and I have just purchased a place and want to downsize the fleet to a single boat.. looking for some advice from the community on what you would do.

For context.. We have a 30' boat slip at Milltown Marina. We fish heavily in September, do 1-2 trips to the west coast a year and then the rest of the time is spent touring the local islands and boat/island camping (5-6 trips a year). I own a cummins pickup and towing is not really an issue for any of the boats.

Boats:

1988 Arima 17 Sea Chaser - new Suzuki 90hp and 9.9hp with remote throttle. Boat has new electronics, radar/arch etc. It gets close to 6mpg and has been a fantastic fair weather boat. I've had it miles offshore but she does pound a bit in the chop. It has full canvas and is just a really great, simple fishing boat. Not great as a family boat.

2003 Tropy 2359 Converted to outboard - 2014 Suzuki 300hp and 20hp. Custom dual helm, diesel heater.. older electronics. This boat is the ultimate family boat. The trailer was recently rebuilt and it tows fairly easy. Handles the water well.. but not nearly as nice as the grady. Its a great platform for winter fishing/prawning and family trips as we can keep the dog and kid contained in the pilothouse.

2004 Grady White Gulfstream - newer Yamaha 300hp and 9.9hp. Remote throttle but just one steering station. Very reliable and safe. I have a tri axle trailer (that needs a lot of maintenance) we use to tow it around. We've owned this one for around 11 years now and has been amazing. But it only seats 2 people under cover and is not a great overnight platform with kids.

If you had to downsize to a single boat to handle fishing, local cruising, sleepovers etc.. what would it be and why?

Appreciate the feedback as always!
 
There will be lots of opinions on this one, but I would go with the Arima.
Plenty of boat for local waters and with new power you'll get at least 10 years with
minimum expense.
Obviously not the best choice for sleeping.
 
Last edited:
Hi all,

My dad and I are both boat enthusiasts and have found ourselves with too many boats. Simply a problem I never thought could exist.

My family and I have just purchased a place and want to downsize the fleet to a single boat.. looking for some advice from the community on what you would do.

For context.. We have a 30' boat slip at Milltown Marina. We fish heavily in September, do 1-2 trips to the west coast a year and then the rest of the time is spent touring the local islands and boat/island camping (5-6 trips a year). I own a cummins pickup and towing is not really an issue for any of the boats.

Boats:

1988 Arima 17 Sea Chaser - new Suzuki 90hp and 9.9hp with remote throttle. Boat has new electronics, radar/arch etc. It gets close to 6mpg and has been a fantastic fair weather boat. I've had it miles offshore but she does pound a bit in the chop. It has full canvas and is just a really great, simple fishing boat. Not great as a family boat.

2003 Tropy 2359 Converted to outboard - 2014 Suzuki 300hp and 20hp. Custom dual helm, diesel heater.. older electronics. This boat is the ultimate family boat. The trailer was recently rebuilt and it tows fairly easy. Handles the water well.. but not nearly as nice as the grady. Its a great platform for winter fishing/prawning and family trips as we can keep the dog and kid contained in the pilothouse.

2004 Grady White Gulfstream - newer Yamaha 300hp and 9.9hp. Remote throttle but just one steering station. Very reliable and safe. I have a tri axle trailer (that needs a lot of maintenance) we use to tow it around. We've owned this one for around 11 years now and has been amazing. But it only seats 2 people under cover and is not a great overnight platform with kids.

If you had to downsize to a single boat to handle fishing, local cruising, sleepovers etc.. what would it be and why?

Appreciate the feedback as always!
Podded Commander 30. If I could drop 300k on a build I'd do it tomorrow
 
Hi all,

My dad and I are both boat enthusiasts and have found ourselves with too many boats. Simply a problem I never thought could exist.

My family and I have just purchased a place and want to downsize the fleet to a single boat.. looking for some advice from the community on what you would do.

For context.. We have a 30' boat slip at Milltown Marina. We fish heavily in September, do 1-2 trips to the west coast a year and then the rest of the time is spent touring the local islands and boat/island camping (5-6 trips a year). I own a cummins pickup and towing is not really an issue for any of the boats.

Boats:

1988 Arima 17 Sea Chaser - new Suzuki 90hp and 9.9hp with remote throttle. Boat has new electronics, radar/arch etc. It gets close to 6mpg and has been a fantastic fair weather boat. I've had it miles offshore but she does pound a bit in the chop. It has full canvas and is just a really great, simple fishing boat. Not great as a family boat.

2003 Tropy 2359 Converted to outboard - 2014 Suzuki 300hp and 20hp. Custom dual helm, diesel heater.. older electronics. This boat is the ultimate family boat. The trailer was recently rebuilt and it tows fairly easy. Handles the water well.. but not nearly as nice as the grady. Its a great platform for winter fishing/prawning and family trips as we can keep the dog and kid contained in the pilothouse.

2004 Grady White Gulfstream - newer Yamaha 300hp and 9.9hp. Remote throttle but just one steering station. Very reliable and safe. I have a tri axle trailer (that needs a lot of maintenance) we use to tow it around. We've owned this one for around 11 years now and has been amazing. But it only seats 2 people under cover and is not a great overnight platform with kids.

If you had to downsize to a single boat to handle fishing, local cruising, sleepovers etc.. what would it be and why?

Appreciate the feedback as always!
Keep the trophy 2359. I’d say a podded 2359 is a very desirable boat for Westcoast fishing and family outings.
 
I am getting a slope back cover made for my 232 to improve overnighting with the family.. will make the deck a huge enclosed area that will be great for sleeping/cooking etc..
 
Hi all,

My dad and I are both boat enthusiasts and have found ourselves with too many boats. Simply a problem I never thought could exist.

My family and I have just purchased a place and want to downsize the fleet to a single boat.. looking for some advice from the community on what you would do.

For context.. We have a 30' boat slip at Milltown Marina. We fish heavily in September, do 1-2 trips to the west coast a year and then the rest of the time is spent touring the local islands and boat/island camping (5-6 trips a year). I own a cummins pickup and towing is not really an issue for any of the boats.

Boats:

1988 Arima 17 Sea Chaser - new Suzuki 90hp and 9.9hp with remote throttle. Boat has new electronics, radar/arch etc. It gets close to 6mpg and has been a fantastic fair weather boat. I've had it miles offshore but she does pound a bit in the chop. It has full canvas and is just a really great, simple fishing boat. Not great as a family boat.

2003 Tropy 2359 Converted to outboard - 2014 Suzuki 300hp and 20hp. Custom dual helm, diesel heater.. older electronics. This boat is the ultimate family boat. The trailer was recently rebuilt and it tows fairly easy. Handles the water well.. but not nearly as nice as the grady. Its a great platform for winter fishing/prawning and family trips as we can keep the dog and kid contained in the pilothouse.

2004 Grady White Gulfstream - newer Yamaha 300hp and 9.9hp. Remote throttle but just one steering station. Very reliable and safe. I have a tri axle trailer (that needs a lot of maintenance) we use to tow it around. We've owned this one for around 11 years now and has been amazing. But it only seats 2 people under cover and is not a great overnight platform with kids.

If you had to downsize to a single boat to handle fishing, local cruising, sleepovers etc.. what would it be and why?

Appreciate the feedback as always!
Trophy. Being able to have multiple people under cover and warm is the best. If there was more salmon fishing and you loved tuna fishing and plans to take it down to Cali for tuna etc, I'd keep the Grady and add a camper back.
 
Trophy, it’s has a cabin and lots of deck space for family and fishing. Camping on a boat with a camper back is just not the same as a closed cabin, I have been down that road. You will recoup a decent amount from the Grady/Arima sales so win win for your family
 
Definitely get rid of that podded 2359, I’ll even help you out 😉.
Are you done with 1 kid or no? Everyone will keep growing so more room the better. Mine love hiding away in a cuddy, though you have that in both so I supposed the decision is a more fishing oriented or a do all comfort rig.
 
Back
Top