Property Assessments Now Available

I will be doing an appeal again this year. I am still trying to understand why a smaller lot is assessed at a higher value than a larger lot.

We have the smallest lot in the neighbourhood by over half it is 23 feet wide and our house is just over 2000 square feet and yet our land is valued significantly higher that 60 foot lots twice the size with 4500 Sq foot homes.

One thing I have learned if you are doing an appeal BC Assessment will asign someone to help you with your assessment.

Imagine my surprise when the staff person "helping" me, turned up to argue against me at the Appeals Board.They had time to prepare counter arguments.

Now that I am retired I have more time to devote to these matters.
Grrrr doesn’t get much more frustrating. Layers of government systems that don’t work. Hope you get yours sorted. I was at “service bc” yesterday, at least the government employee was good but the red tape is driving me out of business.
 
Apparently BC assessment does access building permits to set valuations, which I suspect is why my neighbors all had nice 20-25K drops and mine only dropped 1K. It's reinforces why you never let assessors into your house to look around and always put the bare value on any building permits.
Back this past fall I had someone from BC Assessment phone me regarding a secondary suite conversion I was doing for a client. The project wasn't yet complete and the permit was still open. I can only assume they knew about the work because of the building permit. All they were interested in was if any new living space had been added, to which the answer was no. Turning an existing but unpermitted suite into a legal one by upgrading to proper fire separation assemblies, separating HVAC, etc, plus some nicer finishes.

I just looked up their 2025 assessment and the value has fallen by 4%, which is actually a greater loss than the average across Penticton (-2%). Not sure though when the cutoff time is for 2025. Might be that the suite conversion isn't seen in assessment value until 2026, since both land and buildings values dropped YOY. I've had several similar contacts from BC Assessment over the years, but never have they asked to visit the site. I think most of their assessment is based on basics like living space area and nearby property values.
 
Eby’s wealth tax plan. Spread the wealth around. Slowly taking shape. One progressive move at a time. ‘Don’t worry, it’s not gonna cost you anything. It’ll all be paid by your estate when you’re long gone. Why should that matter to you.” Socialism…..where the misery is shared equally.
 
My assessment was up 8%this year while the luxury houses next to me were up 4 and 5%. I complained about my overall assessment. I do have an appraisal diploma (4 Year) from UBC so went about comparing all the properties in the neighborhood. My house is a spec grade house in a very upmarket luxury neighborhood-The assessment people got back to me-took a lot of work on my part but they offered to lower by 135K-however I could appeal if I felt that wasn't right. I agreed to that as I really didn't want the work a formal complaint entailed. Interestingly enough I had a better case for lowering the land value based on size and lesser water frontage-pretty self explanatory numbers but no -they just dismissed it as "rounding", Time to move on and savour one small and probably my only victory with the BC Assessment
 
It’s Intresting by the reports on here you would think most of the complaints want them to lower the value but I wonder if they get just as many from people that think it’s undervalued
 
It’s Intresting by the reports on here you would think most of the complaints want them to lower the value but I wonder if they get just as many from people that think it’s undervalued
I doubt anyone on here would complain about undervalued assessments since it directly affects how much tax you pay. It could be argued that potential buyers MAY look at assessments to get a feel what they should offer for a house- it really isn't a precise market value. So no real benefit! Most people haven't bought their house as an investment but as a home. Some may feel it is a confirmation of all the sacrifices they went through to own it and now it is worth so much more than they paid for it. Really just a tool for the government to keep inflating value and treating it like a piggy bank that they can raid for more money
 
They don’t have to have your property go up in value tho to raise property taxes.

So I assume the game would be to have the lowest assessed house in the neighborhood so you would be under the average
 
Looking at mine for example the house makes up 10% of the value and I assume it’s probably harder to argue about the land value portion.

Total value
$1,137,000
2025 assessment as of July 1, 2024

Land $1,001,000

Buildings $136,000

Previous year value

$1,164,000

Land $1,050,000

Buildings $114,000
 
They don’t have to have your property go up in value tho to raise property taxes.

So I assume the game would be to have the lowest assessed house in the neighborhood so you would be under the average
Taxes you pay depend on the mill rate that the municipality or your town or city levels. This of course depends on the budget they pass. As for assessments all you can hope for is that it is fair. In my case I built a smallish spec quality home on a waterfront lot because there is just my wife and I and it was the waterfront that was important to us. We were fine for a few years-then these 4 to 5000 sq ft luxury homes were built mostly by absent owners and suddenly assessment values started to increase by huge amounts. My assessment as a % seemed to increase greater than theirs. Finally I am looking at a 5000 sq foot luxury home with 6 baths with an assessed sq foot value of $311. My spec house with 2 baths and End of the Roll carpet was $403. I had to object-but mine is the cheapest home in the neighborhood and of course the natural tendency by them is to try and even out the assessments. That is what I think happened over the course of 5 years. So you should be vigilant because over assessment can happen but you need to document it.
 
Last edited:
Looking at mine for example the house makes up 10% of the value and I assume it’s probably harder to argue about the land value portion.

Total value
$1,137,000
2025 assessment as of July 1, 2024

Land $1,001,000

Buildings $136,000

Previous year value

$1,164,000

Land $1,050,000

Buildings $114,000
Haha just took a better look at mine and my building is only worth $72,000.00 hahaha. The two rotten rental houses across the street are each worth $120,000 on the buildings.
 
Looking at my neighbors is funny, went up 260k buildings the same inside and out. only difference was it sold so they just changed the assessment to what it pretty much sold at?

Total value

$1,393,000
2025 assessment as of July 1, 2024

Land $971,000

Buildings $422,000




Previous year value

$1,129,000

Land $1,019,000

Buildings $110,000

Sales history (last 3 full calendar years)
Feb 12, 2024$1,396,000
 
Looking at my neighbors is funny, went up 260k buildings the same inside and out. only difference was it sold so they just changed the assessment to what it pretty much sold at?

Total value

$1,393,000
2025 assessment as of July 1, 2024

Land $971,000

Buildings $422,000




Previous year value

$1,129,000

Land $1,019,000

Buildings $110,000

Sales history (last 3 full calendar years)

Feb 12, 2024$1,396,000
They would do that because their assessment purports to be the VALUE of the property as of july 1 2024. There is no better proof of value than somebody willingly paying that much money. Better insight into the market than all the educated guesses. Expect the neighbourhood assessments to rise next year--be very hard to fight with an actual cash example available.
 
Last edited:
Yeah I think the top and bottom is bei being rented out so I don’t no how they factor that in or maybe they don’t but definitely the system does seem jank.

I just find it Intresting how they choose to just jack up the building portion rather then the land portion.
 
Last week, we had to go to Vancouver to deal with proving my mother-in-law lives in her house and the house is not vacant. We filled out and sent in the declaration but got audited.

My mother-in-law has lived in her house for 50+ years and is 92 yrs old. Her first languish is finish and has no computer or tech skills and is not mobile. We had to go to Van and to city hall to provide copies of a power bills, past house taxes and phone bills to city to prove she still is living in the home.

The house is in East Van and on a 33'X120' residence lot and has a 2,200 sq ft home (Van Special) built in 1974. House tax value assessment is $60K.

If we didn’t provide the information they were requesting the empty tax invoice is $53,160.00. Plus the regular tax of $6K
 
I spent a good part of last Friday preparing our initial appeal. Apparently, the smaller the lot the more valuable it is in the eyes of BC Assessment .

They are using as a comparable a house that I had the Appeals Board toss out becasue it was even to the untrained eye, far more valuable, luxurious, and in a far nicer area than I live in.
 
I spent a good part of last Friday preparing our initial appeal. Apparently, the smaller the lot the more valuable it is in the eyes of BC Assessment .

They are using as a comparable a house that I had the Appeals Board toss out becasue it was even to the untrained eye, far more valuable, luxurious, and in a far nicer area than I live in.
Are you OK with inviting them into your house? If there’s anything in there that hasn’t been disclosed in the past as an addition or renovation, it will be included going forward.
 
Brutal. I hate it when people say Canada is broken but Bill and Doug should be doing fun things in their retirement, spending money and fishing.

I don't mind doing the appeals. It is good for my brain and I really like to stand up and fight the good fight when it is needed. Our office building security guard suffered a stroke and for a long time he had limited mobility and speech.

We did a fundraiser in our office building for him and raised a little more than 5K. human services decided that until he spent all that money he would not be entitled to social benefits and , then when the money was gone their plan was to put him into one of those SRO slum buildings on Hastings street.

He came to me and appointed me as his spokesperson and PA. Five of them came to a meeting in our office and I knew we were getting somewhere when two people told me that they didn't feel safe .

I explained that since we had 3 senior women from our firm in the room and were recording the meeting I would send them a copy .

I said that I was more concerned that we were dealing with racial discrimination (my buddy was black) and that no one had even asked about his education, training and experience . I was then told that it was offensive that I suggested that might have happened .

I said I bet if my buddy was a college graduate more would be done.

I get the eye rolls and then gasps as I produced his two Masters Degrees one from Africa and the other from a name school in Germany.

He and a bunch of similar folks had been brought to the US on a work contract that would lead to citizenship. His whole department was let go the week before they would be eligable and had to leave the US He was able to come to Canada and then worked as a Security guard

3 years later he was back working full time security with a minor speech impediment
 
Back
Top