C&R works if people are educated on how to do it correctly. This summer in my local fishery I saw stunningly bad behavior with wild chinook hook-ups….(wild chinook are 100% mandatory C&R) ….
Every boat, and I mean every boat, netted EVERY fish they hooked…there was zero attempt to even look at the fish and see what they had before the net came out….the fish was netted and came over the gunnel into the boat….then if it was determined to be wild (while flopping in the net on the deck) it was finally either removed from the net and tossed over board or the net was placed back in the water and turned inside out.
Many of these boats were sophisticated fish-catching machines. I was floored watching this behavior from people who should have known better
If I was a fishery manager, I’d be very tempted to count these C&R disasters as a 50% mortality data point. I know they already count “incidents” of juvenile chinook catches as a mortality and close down fisheries when those “incidents” reach a certain threshold.
It blows my mind how uninformed (or lazy) people are in these fisheries. This automatic reaching for a net on every fish has to change when it comes to chinook C&R. Meanwhile, I had hoped the guides in that fleet would have shown better behavior but they were the worst.