I think the round d/balls are the best shape.
"pancakes' and 'fish' shaped weights can tend to swim off course. Especially in current.
And they aren't ergonomically better. They present more water surface area to create drag than a round ball.
I like the round balls with a little fin at the back.
Years back they did tests on different shapes /sizes and found the round ones to be the most efficient.
Round balls with no fins will have the best weight to surface area shape and will go deeper than any other shape.
However most round balls also have a fin that adds to the surface area causing more friction/blow back than the plain round ball giving them less of an advantage over the other shape out there.
I drag bottom to often to run anything other than round ones
I've heard the old chestnut about bending the fin on the pancake weight to get it to swim "outward" a little more. Which only works if you are at a certain speed in ideal water.
Do the fish shaped weights blow back less than the cannonball style? 12-15#
We find the pancakes weights run deeper with smaller line angles. To prevent issues with the current and fins bend the fins opposite directions on each side so they naturally pull away from the boat. We run a pancake on each side, and a round cannonball on the back of the boat and rarely have any tangles even in the currents around Victoria.
Check these outI had a daydream the other day that is essentially a cross between a DR ball and a planer....not with full on wings which could cause big problems and more blow back but add some slight hydrodymanic tweaks to the shape to give it some downward force so you could essentially get the performance of a 15lb with 10lb of lead. I think there could be something there...
I've got one-the numbers they give don't appear to be accurate there's a helluva lotta blowback.Check these outhttp://zwingdownrigger.com