Trophy gets a lot of bad press for sure, but as you say, people I know that have them seem to like them. I think some of the bad rep might be Bayliner in general, which turns out some crappy cheap boats at the low end of their line (brand new 17' bowrider with small inboard and trailer, $12k, that's cheap....but get what you pay for?). I think Trophy is their higher end line.
I like the layout too, for their walkaround cuddys, similar to Arimas and to Campion 542, which is what I eventually bought.